×
Register Here to Apply for Jobs or Post Jobs. X

Senior Arbitration Manager

Job in Carmel, Hamilton County, Indiana, 46032, USA
Listing for: OPENLANE
Full Time position
Listed on 2026-01-04
Job specializations:
  • Management
    Operations Manager
Job Description & How to Apply Below

Who We Are:
At OPENLANE we make wholesale easy so our customers can be more successful.

We’re a technology company building the world’s most advanced—and uncomplicated—digital marketplace for used vehicles.
We’re a data company helping customers buy and sell smarter with clear, actionable insights they can understand and use.
And we’re an innovation company accelerating the future of wholesale remarketing through curiosity, collaboration, and an entrepreneurial spirit.

Our Values:
Driven Way builders. We pursue challenges that inspire us to build, create, and innovate.
Relentless Curiosity. We seek to understand and improve our customers’ experience.
Smart Risk-Taking. We transform risk into progress through data, experience, and intuition.
Fearless Ownership. We deliver what we promise and learn along the way.

We’re Looking For:

We are seeking a Senior Arbitration Manager with experience in customer service and automotive environments. You will lead a team of Arbitration Support Representatives responsible for the resolution of customers discrepancies on all mechanically related vehicle issues post-sale. In this role, you will have the opportunity to ensure timely and successful resolution of the arbitration on vehicles. The ideal candidate will have 5+ years of experience in an automotive, mechanical, or body shop environment.

You Are:

  • Customer Focused. You will maintain a fair, consistent, and balanced marketplace for both buyers and sellers on the OPENLANE Marketplace.

  • Analytical. You will review complex arbitration cases and work with agents to find fair solutions.

  • Results Driven. You will connect the day-to-day decisions to the larger monthly and annual goals.

  • A Coach. You will work shoulder to shoulder with agents to improve performance - providing feedback to reinforce positives and help agents to improve performance gaps.

You Will:

  • Review and assess mechanical issues brought to our attention from buyers purchasing vehicles on our platform

  • Understand customer descriptions of symptoms to diagnose and clarify the mechanical issue(s)

  • Learn and apply company policies to resolve arbitration in a timely and equitable manner

  • Mediate, dispute, and negotiate repair and/or pricing of disputed vehicles to arrive at a mutually agreeable solution

  • Document and maintain accurate files for each arbitration case

  • Collaborate with different departments to reach successful resolution of claim

Who You Will Work With :

  • Reporting to the Director of Arbitrations, this role will collaborate with the Arbitration Support Representatives on a regular basis.

  • Interact with sales representatives and leadership; answering questions and resolving concerns regarding the arbitration process.

Must Have’s:

  • 5 years of automotive, mechanical, or body shop experience

  • Proficient use of CRM software

  • Strong customer service focus with excellent communication skills

  • Ability to verify and confirm vehicle condition data from vehicle inspection reports

Nice to Have’s:

  • Experience coaching and developing individuals to achieve goals

  • Ability to analyze a process and suggest/develop improvements

  • Change leadership experience

What We Offer:

  • Competitive pay

  • Medical, dental, and vision benefits with employer HSA contributions (US) and FSA options (US)

  • Immediately vested 401K (US) or RRSP (Canada) with company match

  • Paid Vacation, Personal, and Sick Time

  • Paid maternity and paternity leave (US)

  • Employer-paid short-term disability, long-term disability, life insurance, and AD&D (US)

  • Robust Employee Assistance Program

  • Employer paid Leap into Service Day to volunteer

  • Tuition Reimbursement for eligible programs

  • Opportunities to expand your skill set and share your knowledge across a publicly traded, global organization

  • Company culture of internal promotions, diverse career paths, and meaningful advancement

Sound like a match? Apply Now - We can't wait to hear from you!

Position Requirements
10+ Years work experience
To View & Apply for jobs on this site that accept applications from your location or country, tap the button below to make a Search.
(If this job is in fact in your jurisdiction, then you may be using a Proxy or VPN to access this site, and to progress further, you should change your connectivity to another mobile device or PC).
 
 
 
Search for further Jobs Here:
(Try combinations for better Results! Or enter less keywords for broader Results)
Location
Increase/decrease your Search Radius (miles)

Job Posting Language
Employment Category
Education (minimum level)
Filters
Education Level
Experience Level (years)
Posted in last:
Salary