Insurance Agent

Insurance Agent (Base Salary + Uncapped Commissions)

Base pay range: $56,000.00/yr - $65,000.00/yr

Typical starting salary is influenced by skills, experience, education, certifications, and location. The full salary range reflects competitive labor‑market values across the national market and allows for progression as employees grow and develop within the role. Many positions at Liberty Mutual include additional commission and/or bonus earnings.

We’re hiring a Sales Agent to join our team! This role centers on building strong, in‑person relationships within the local community, so success depends on your ability to network and connect face‑to‑face. The position requires in‑office presence.

Candidates must reside in Madison, Stevens Point, Appleton, or Milwaukee, WI.

• Typical training salary: $55k – $65k
• Base, bonuses, and uncapped commissions typically total first‑year compensation ranging from $55k – $75k
• Top performers can earn over $100k in their first year

• Highly self‑motivated and driven: resilient, strong work ethic, independent after training, natural leader, excellent time‑management.
• Gritty and adaptable: thrives under pressure, adapts to change, takes ownership of results.
• Coachable: team player who loves to learn, welcomes feedback, seeks continuous improvement.
• Results‑oriented: competitive, motivated by friendly rivalry, goes above and beyond to achieve goals.
• Charismatic: people‑person who enjoys helping communities stay safe, cultivates relationships, and boasts strong influencing skills.

• Uncapped pay that includes base salary and bonuses, with renewal commissions.
• Recognition through prizes and worldwide travel.
• Paid training (including licensing) and mentorship opportunities.
• Sales support, including commission for leads even if other teammates close the deals.
• Comprehensive benefits from day one: health & dental insurance, 401(k) with company match, paid pension, paid time off, 401(k) student‑loan match, tuition reimbursement, family‑building support.

• Previous sales role with proven ability to turn prospects into customers.
• State insurance license in Property & Casualty, and Life, or willingness to obtain one with training.

• Effective written and oral communication and presentation skills.
• Well‑developed persuasion and negotiation skills.
• Great interpersonal skills and proven ability to build relationships with prospective and existing customers.
• Effective time management and organizational skills.
• Ability to learn insurance coverage and underwriting guidelines.
• Familiarity with building and growing leads and customer base.

Comparion Insurance Agency was created in 2022 to transition former Liberty Mutual exclusive agents to an agency delivering a unique value proposition to carriers with over 2,000 agents in 44 states. We offer coverage from 50 insurance companies across a wide product range. Our leadership boasts over 200 years of cumulative experience.

Liberty Mutual is an equal‑opportunity employer. We will not tolerate discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, religion, age, disability, veteran's status, pregnancy, genetic information, or any other basis prohibited by law.

• California
• Los Angeles Incorporated
• Los Angeles Unincorporated
• Philadelphia
• San Francisco

Not Applicable

Full‑time

Sales and Business Development

Insurance