Account Manager Insurance Sales

Benefits:

Extended Paid Holidays

401(k) matching

Bonus based on performance

Dental insurance

Flexible schedule

Free food & snacks

Paid time off

Parental leave

Training & development

Vision insurance

If you're tired of playing small and ready to bet on yourself, this is your role. At Team Prahl, we don’t believe in caps on income or waiting your turn. We believe in doing big things — and letting the right people run with their talent. We're looking for someone who wants to do meaningful work, make real money, and be part of a team where your ideas are heard and your results matter.

We're on a mission to find the top 1% — the kind of person who doesn’t just go the extra mile but builds the road while they’re eone who shows up with energy, is strategic and solution-oriented, someone who can spot opportunity, and makes life better just by being in the room. You know the type. Maybe it’s you. Maybe it’s someone you know.

Either way, we want to meet them.

Location:

Hybrid/Remote/In Person

Hours:

Flexible

Position:
Insurance Sales — Full Time

Team:
Marta Prahl American Family Insurance Agency - Monroe WI

Your Day-to-Day

Using consultative sales skills to connect real people with real protection

Prospecting like a pro — through calls, networking, community events, hobbies, and hustle

Conducting smart, thoughtful client meetings that lead to long-term relationships

Bringing marketing ideas to life - from grassroots campaigns to digital outreach

Representing a brand people actually remember — and trust

You Might Be a Fit If You

Are a self-starter who thrives on autonomy and results

Can easily connect with people and communicate with confidence

Are looking to be great at something that matters

Are looking for meaningful work that helps people and builds your future at the same time

Are a person with purpose and loves growth - yours and everyone else's

Pay Details:

Expected Pay in Year 1: $40,600 - $50,000+

Additional Expected Bonuses: $1,000 - $8,500 (dependent on your sales results)

Year 2:
Additional income through renewals of previously sold policies

Year 2+:
Top performers easily hit $100,000+. Additional income through renewals of previously sold policies. The more you close, the more you take home. No cap.

Other Benefits:

Health, Dental, Vision benefits

Parental leave

401k with Company Match

Unlimited time off

Great Business Hours (Monday - Thursday: 9:00am – 4:30pm, Friday: 9:00am - 4:00pm Central Time)

Flexible Schedule Options (An alternative schedule may be discussed after training period)

Ability to work partially from home (upon conclusion of training period)

This isn’t corporate red tape. It’s your chance to own your growth, your income, and your future — with a team that actually has your back.

Message us now. Send this to someone amazing. Don’t let this sit. Opportunity’s knocking!

This position is an Agency Team Member working for the Agency Owner and is not an employee of American Family Insurance.