Claims Supervisor III - Property & Casualty
Listed on 2026-10-14
-
Insurance
Risk Manager/Analyst, Insurance Claims
Position:Claims Supervisor III - Property & Casualty
Claims Supervisor III – Property & Casualty
Department:
Property & Casualty
Reports To:
Claims Manager Property & Casualty
FLSA Status:
Exempt
Job Grade:
16
ATHENS ADMINISTRATORSExplore the Athens Administrators difference:
We have been dynamic, innovative leaders in claims administration since our founding in 1976. We foster an environment where employees not only thrive but consistently recognize Athens as a “Best Place to Work.” Immerse yourself in our engaging, supportive, and inclusive culture, offering opportunities for continuous professional growth. Join our nationwide family-owned company in Workers' Compensation, Property & Casualty, Program Business, and Managed Care.
Embrace a change and come make an impact with the Athens Administrators family today!
Athens Administrators has an immediate need for a full-time Claims Supervisor III to support our Property & Casualty department. Management that lives less than 36 miles from our local office AND have a direct report in the office, are required to work once a week in the office. The remaining days can be worked remotely if technical requirements are met, and the employee lives in a state we operate in (includes CA, CT, FL, GA, , IL, MA, NY, NC, NJ, OH, OK, OR, PA, SC, TN, TX, VA and WV).
Athens offices are open for business Monday-Friday from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Athens Program Insurance Services is the centerpiece of P&C claims administration in the specialty programs marketplace. We are totally unique in that we focus only on commercial business specialization across multiple coverage lines. The Claims Supervisor is responsible for supervising, directing, and coordinating the activities of a team handling complex liability claims within assigned authority limits and consistent with good faith handling practices.
These claims are typically mid to high exposure. The goal of the position is to ensure the delivery of quality service to customers while protecting their interests.
Our new hire should have the skills, ability, and judgment to perform the following essential job duties and responsibilities with or without reasonable accommodation. Additional duties may be assigned:
- Responsible for handling a unit of senior and complex examiners handling claims of a severe and complex nature involving bodily injury, property damage, occurrence or claims made and complex coverage. Exposures are typically valued at levels of 100K or higher
- Able to handle multiple coverage lines with specific concentration on high exposure Auto, GL, PL (E&O) involving varying program segments
- Plans, schedules, and supervises the work activities of the unit's personnel in reviewing, analyzing, investigating, negotiating, and settling claims in compliance with established standards and expectations
- Reviews claim loss reports, assesses complexity of submitted claims and assures claims are assigned to appropriate personnel (based on licensure, knowledge, skills, and abilities) to ensure optimal claims handling within team; serves as a technical resource for staff as necessary
- Reviews and approves, within assigned authority limits, claim expenses and settlements that exceed the claim adjusters granted authority; appropriately refers claim expenses and settlements that exceed personal authority limits for approval
- Oversight of complex and reportable litigation and coverage cases. Serves as the primary liaison between the examiners and clients on case conferences and referrals
- Must be able to interpret coverage, provide guidance on coverage matters and review reservation of rights and DISCLAIMERS for carrier approval
- Monitors and evaluates reserves for claims within the unit to…
(If this job is in fact in your jurisdiction, then you may be using a Proxy or VPN to access this site, and to progress further, you should change your connectivity to another mobile device or PC).