Skip to content
×

Customer Services Supervisor

Job in Van Wert, Van Wert County, Ohio, 45891, USA
Listing for: Van Wert Works
Full Time position Listed on 2026-11-13
Job specializations:
Salary/Wage Range or Industry Benchmark: 63700 - 85000 USD Yearly USD 63700.00 85000.00 YEAR

Job Description & How to Apply Below

800 S. Washington Street
Van Wert, OH45891

Central Insurance has been family owned and operating since 1876, and we’re just getting started. We’re a property and casualty insurance group that believes great work starts with Integrity, thrives on strong Relationships, and never settles for less than Excellence. With over $2B in assets and an A (Excellent) A.M. Best rating, we offer stability, opportunity, and a team you’ll actually enjoy being part of.

We make a difference for our policyholders by providing excellent service and being there in the greatest times of need.

About the Role

We’re a team of employees passionate about delivering best-in‑class customer service and driving innovation in claims management. Integrity, relationships, and excellence are at the heart of everything we do.

Our employees fully utilize their talents and bring their best selves to work. We believe who you are is just as important as what you do!

Be the Voice Behind Exceptional Customer Experiences

At Central Insurance, our customers count on us to make insurance interactions simple, helpful, and meaningful. Our Customer Service team is at the heart of that mission—delivering outstanding support, solving problems, and building trusted relationships every day. As a
Customer Service Supervisor, you’ll help policyholders and agents navigate billing and policy questions, provide solutions that make a difference, and contribute to a culture focused on service excellence. If you’re energized by helping others, solving challenges, and creating positive customer experiences, we’d love to have you join our team.

What we are looking for
  • Bachelor’s degree and 1 year customer services experience
  • 3 years customer services experience
  • Occasional travel for purposes of training and leadership development
  • Experienced people leadership- preferred
What you’ll do
  • Proactively perpetuates the culture, embraces Central’s core values, and supports Central’s services mission
  • Demonstrates a hospitality mindset reflective of the expectations set forth including building rapport, credibility, a positive attitude, and teamwork to all customers
  • Builds relationships, communicates, and collaborates with peer services leaders and all other internal/external stakeholder
  • Communicates strategy and priorities, sets expectations, holds team accountable, and gets results.
  • Leads, develops, and mentors team through onboarding and subject matter expertise training progression
  • Ensures team is providing proactive customer service by appropriately setting expectations, building rapport, and responding to requests timely
  • Seeks continuous improvement opportunities and proposes solutions
  • Monitors, evaluates, and coaches performance of team members
  • Conducts monthly check‑ins and annual performance appraisals
  • Manages productivity/efficiency, quality, accuracy, and timeliness
  • Interviews and assists in the selection of new employees
  • Leads project work and initiatives as assigned
  • Assists with production duties and services external customers as needed
  • Reports workload and employee productivity to stakeholders; analyzes and makes suggestions on improvements
  • Assists manager in analyzing workloads, staffing and resources
  • Distributes internal reports
  • Ensures proper systems access to vendor sites
  • Oversees and co‑owns the billing system
  • Regular attendance at required meetings, training events, and business functions is an essential function of this role. Periodic travel may be required to support these activities.
Hiring Range

$63,700–$85,000
represents typical starting salaries and is a portion of the full pay range for the role.

Starting pay is determined based on several factors, including relevant experience, education, skills, and certifications. The full pay range is broader and is…

To View & Apply for jobs on this site that accept applications from your location or country, tap the button below to make a Search.
(If this job is in fact in your jurisdiction, then you may be using a Proxy or VPN to access this site, and to progress further, you should change your connectivity to another mobile device or PC).
View / Apply for Jobs
Matching My Jurisdiction

Search for further Jobs Here:

SEARCH JOBS: 10+ Million Listings
(Try combinations for better Results! Or enter less keywords for broader Results)
Education Level
Experience Level (years)
Posted in last:
Salary