Controller; Non-Profit

Position: Controller (Non-Profit)
Controller (Non-Profit)
Indianapolis, IN
Hybrid schedule (up to 2 days work from home)
$95,000 - $120,000 base salary (flexible based on experience and nonprofit complexity)

A mission-driven organization in the Indianapolis area is seeking a Controller to lead accounting operations and ensure financial integrity in support of organizational goals. This role is ideal for an experienced accounting professional with nonprofit experience who enjoys blending hands-on accounting with leadership, oversight, and strategic collaboration.

The Controller will play a key role in financial reporting, compliance, and process improvement while partnering closely with leadership to support transparency and stewardship of funds.
Key Responsibilities

• Oversee all accounting operations, including general ledger, month-end close, and financial reporting
• Prepare and review monthly, quarterly, and annual financial statements
• Ensure compliance with nonprofit accounting standards, including GAAP and fund accounting
• Manage budgeting, forecasting, and variance analysis in collaboration with leadership
• Oversee grant tracking, restricted funds, and donor-related reporting
• Coordinate annual audits and serve as the primary point of contact for external auditors
• Maintain and strengthen internal controls and accounting policies
• Lead and develop accounting staff; provide guidance, training, and oversight
• Support process improvements and system efficiencies within the accounting function

Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree in Accounting, Finance, or related field (required)
• 5-10+ years of progressive accounting experience, ideally within a nonprofit organization
• Strong knowledge of nonprofit accounting, including fund and grant accounting
• Prior experience in a controller, assistant controller, or accounting manager role
• Experience managing or mentoring accounting staff
• Strong understanding of internal controls and audit processes
• Proficiency with accounting systems and Excel
• CPA preferred but not required

Compensation & Opportunity

• Base salary range of $95K-$120K, depending on experience
• Hybrid work environment with remote flexibility
• High-impact leadership role supporting a mission-driven organization
• Opportunity to influence financial strategy and operational improvements
• Stable organization with long-term growth and visibility

EB-