Subrogation Trial Attorney - Hamilton, NJ; Hybrid

About Us

At Selective, we don't just insure uniquely, we employ uniqueness. Selective is a midsized U.S. domestic property and casualty insurance company with a history of strong, consistent financial performance for nearly 100 years. Selective's unique position as both a leading insurance group and an employer of choice is recognized in a wide variety of awards and honors, including listing in Forbes Best Midsize Employers in 2025 and certification as a Great Place to Work® in 2025 for the sixth consecutive year.

Employees are empowered and encouraged to Be Uniquely You by being their true, unique selves and contributing their diverse talents, experiences, and perspectives to our shared success. Together, we are a high-performing team working to serve our customers responsibly by helping to mitigate loss, keep them safe, and restore their lives and businesses after an insured loss occurs.

Selective Insurance is seeking a Subrogation Trial Attorney for our Staff Counsel office in Hamilton, NJ. This is a hybrid role, with 2 days in office and 3 days remote.

Provides legal representation to the Company in prosecution of subrogation claims. Provides advice to the subrogation claims department of the Company. Responsible for managing a case load from investigation and inception to resolution. All job duties and responsibilities must be carried out in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements.

• Independently represents the Company before the assigned Court and presents witnesses and evidence on subrogation litigation claims.
• Analyzes complex legal and factual issues, conducts extensive, well-reasoned legal research, independently develops and presents initial strategies on behalf of the Company.
• Drafts pleadings, written discovery, motions and briefs in support of agreed upon strategies.
• Prepares for, attends and handles all activities related to full trial and/or appeals, as assigned.
• Provides effective and timely communications, information, legal advice and other services to clients and subrogation claims professionals on legal and factual issues adhering to our litigation guidelines.
• Assists in developing training materials for the subrogation Claims Department.
• Communicates with the Court, witnesses, opposing counsel and clients in a manner consistent with established office procedures and the Code of Professional Conduct.
• Responsible for the prompt, efficient and effective disposition of assigned cases.
• Travels to depositions, court appearances, claims and client meetings, and other events as necessary. Car travel represents approximately 20% of employee’s time.
• Keeps current with market trends and demands.
• Attends continuing legal education seminars in order to maintain a high level of professional expertise.
• Performs all other functionally related duties as assigned by the Managing Attorney.
• Provides legal representation to Selectiveon litigated claims.
• Provides advice to our subrogation claims partners and represents Selective in certain litigated matters.
• Responsible for managing a case load from investigation and inception to resolution.
• All job duties and responsibilities must be carried out in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements.
• Analyzes legal and factual issues, conducts legal research, and independently develops and advances agreed upon strategies on behalf of the Company.

• Excellent customer service, writing and oral communication skills required.
• Ability to demonstrate independent judgment, research, litigation, and analytical skills.
• Strong legal research and writing skills required.
• Proficiency in Microsoft Word, Outlook and Edge or Chrome required.
• Legal case management software…